Summer iPad Air Giveaway! 20 Under 40

Blame the Flyers for poor Phantoms seasons

2012-03-23T00:34:00Z 2012-03-23T13:55:42Z Blame the Flyers for poor Phantoms seasonsBy Tim McManus -- Commentary Glens Falls Post-Star
March 23, 2012 12:34 am  • 

Three years ago, the Philadelphia Flyers brass came to town and said they had a two-pronged goal for their AHL affiliate in Glens Falls: develop and win.

I sure hope they got what they wanted out of the development end, because they haven’t come close to winning. With 12 games remaining in this season, a path to the playoffs still exists, but it involves optimistic math and quite a bit of help.

And even so, this is what we’re supposed to be excited about? A desperate struggle just for the small chance to be the team who steps in front of the Norfolk tidal wave?

Look, this isn’t about being naive. If the Flyers win the Stanley Cup this year, no one in the organization is going to miss a second of sleep over what happened with Adirondack.

And I get that. Winning in the NHL is first. It should be. The AHL club is there to support that goal and whatever happens here is gravy.

No one expects Adirondack to be Hershey or St. John’s or Charlotte. The only way to guarantee success each year is when you have local owners willing to foot part of the bill to bring in AHL veterans and those situations are few and far between.

But is it too much to ask for the Flyers to supply Adirondack with something more than the worst team in the league the last three seasons?

The Phantoms have the fewest points in the AHL over the last three years. They’ve finished last in their division two straight seasons and are in the basement again with 12 games remaining. They’ve never finished better than 13th in the conference, exactly where they sit heading into this weekend.

Here’s what the Flyers did this offseason to change that in terms of veteran free-agent acquisitions: they signed Jason Bacashihua as a backup goalie — a position already overfilled.

Bacashihua has been a nice player, but those aren’t the kind of moves that put you over the top.

Contrast that to Springfield, another perennially struggling Northeast franchise. Columbus signed former all-star forwards Martin St. Pierre and Alexandre Giroux. Both have more points than anyone on the perpetually offensively challenged Phantoms.

There’s no doubt this season the Phantoms have done a good job of sending fill-in talent to the next level. Marc-Andre Bourdon, Eric Wellwood, Harry Zolnierczyk, Erik Gustafsson, even Brandon Manning of late, have stepped in and done admirable jobs for the Flyers.

Players that developed here last season like Zac Rinaldo and Tom Sestito have also played with the Flyers.

None of those guys may end up as stars, but they helped the Flyers get through rough patches.

That’s to be lauded. And for some, that will be the be all and end all of the question. They’ve helped the Flyers, ’nuff said.

But this support from the Phantoms is a relatively new development. The last two seasons were remarkably free of call-ups. The back-and-forth movement this season is more in line with what most franchises experience.

The Phantoms’ troubles aren’t a recent development. They were in decline before they were sold by the Flyers to Rob and Jim Brooks and moved here.

Their second Calder Cup came in the lockout season of 2004-05, when many players who’d in other years be with the Flyers stayed with the Phantoms. Since then, they’ve won just one playoff series.

After winning division titles their first three seasons, the Phantoms won just one in their final 10 seasons in Philadelphia. They haven’t won a playoff game since 2008.

There’s been a trickle-down effect of trading away draft picks and trying to win immediately through trades and free agency. Recently, the Flyers just don’t count on major contributions from players brought up through the AHL.

Of their 15 leading scorers this year, only Matt Read and James van Riemsdyk have spent any time with the Phantoms in the last four seasons, and they combined for just 18 games.

With fewer draft picks, the Flyers relied on the undrafted free-agent market to fill Adirondack’s roster. And for every home run like Read, there have been many others who just aren’t ready to contribute offensively in the AHL.

The Flyers aren’t the only NHL team trying to win right now, and somehow, other clubs manage to both develop and be competitive. Wilkes-Barre/Scranton manages to field a strong team each season. Hasn’t hurt the Pittsburgh Penguins.

Binghamton won a Calder Cup last year with a purely developmental model.

But no one here is even asking for a championship. They’re asking for the team to not finish in last place for once. To repeat: no one has put a worse product on the ice in the AHL the last three seasons.

Even if you want to look at the AHL as purely a means to an NHL end — and how many Stanley Cups have the Flyers won lately? — doesn’t the NHL club stocking the roster have at least some responsibility to make the team competitive?

If not to the fans who pay for the tickets, then how about to the owners who pay for the affiliation rights?

Look at what happened in Syracuse this year when owner Howard Dolgon felt like Anaheim didn’t live up to its end of their bargain. He opted out. Cut them loose. And Syracuse has had a better record than the Phantoms the last two years.

With a bonanza waiting in Allentown, the Brookses aren’t about to opt out. And Adirondack fans don’t have a choice.

Fans here have been patient. For more than a year they blamed the coaching. Then the goaltending. Then they mostly just accepted mediocrity and hoped for the best this season from a group of largely likeable and hard-working players.

But there’s nothing left to blame except for the one constant the past three years: the organization selecting the players.

The only thing people can do is appeal to the pride of the Flyers front office.

I’ve followed the Flyers since I was a kid and there’s been one trait they use to define themselves: No one wants to win more.

So isn’t there someone in the organization ticked off that their AHL affiliate — once a league model — has become a laughingstock? Isn’t someone embarrassed when they open the paper and see the standings?

It has to be a matter of philosophy or will, because it surely isn’t about money. With what the Flyers paid to stash Michael Leighton, Matt Walker and Johan Backlund here this season, they could have fielded an AHL all-star team three times over.

There are no more excuses. We know where to look this offseason.

Fix this mess. Fix it this summer.

Tim McManus may be reached at

Follow him on Twitter (@PSPhantoms) and read his daily updates on the Phantoms Forum blog online.

Copyright 2015 Glens Falls Post-Star. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(10) Comments

  1. Jonny
    Report Abuse
    Jonny - March 28, 2012 5:28 am
    Pretty harsh to the players, but that could only be the fault of a biased, backwoods paper like the pointless star. It's not Tim's fault, the paper just spent too much money on real reporters. He tries real hard, though. Maybe someday he'll be as good as Will Dolittle. Obviously, this is the fault of the administration, and not Tim's, that he is such a poor performer. This is why I canceled my subscription, years ago.
  2. beyou02215
    Report Abuse
    beyou02215 - March 26, 2012 6:40 pm
    I don't know. This article is a bit unnecessarily harsh (i.e. "[t]here’s no doubt this season the Phantoms have done a good job of sending fill-in talent to the next level.") and I have to say, we're fortunate to have a team like this here. Everyone wants to root for a winner and I have a feeling that this team is ready to take the next step and go on a serious tear. I know that is easy to say after a 3-0 weekend, but count this fan as a believer. Either way, we should all get behind this team and support them the best we can. If they don't make the playoffs...fine, complain. But its wayyyyy too early to write them off now. Here's to making a deep run in the playoffs!
  3. smpotter
    Report Abuse
    smpotter - March 23, 2012 4:21 pm
    I could not agree with you more on your assessment of the situation here. However, as much as the Brook's have little to no say in player decisions, they are not blameless.Together, I believe the Brook's and the Flyers will signal the end of AHL hockey here in Glens Falls. The Flyers have done very little to ensure that there is a competitive team here. Its been better this year but as you have pointed out we are almost last in the league again. We have done very well supporting a team that is very frustrating . They score very few goals and have rarely put together any kind of a winning streak in three years. Yet, the Brooks Brothers have basically threatened the fans with, "pack the place regardless and we'll talk to our fellow owners about maybe putting another team in Glens Falls". Its all up to us to support a lousy team that plays here from year to year.If we don't get another team its our fault,but I blame the Flyers and the Brooks.
  4. brian
    Report Abuse
    brian - March 23, 2012 4:01 pm
    What the “braintrust” in Philly forgets is that part of development is talent, but part of it is also creating that winning mentality. Environment creates habits. The players here are learning how to be mediocre, not how to challenge for Cups. This won’t serve the Flyers in the future. Maybe this mentality is why they haven’t won a Stanley Cup in 35 years.
  5. brian
    Report Abuse
    brian - March 23, 2012 4:00 pm
    I’m not sure any regular attendee of Phantoms’ games could possibly disagree with Tim’s article.
  6. TheChampion
    Report Abuse
    TheChampion - March 23, 2012 2:21 pm
    You know what I meant!
  7. Tim McManus
    Report Abuse
    Tim McManus - March 23, 2012 1:43 pm

    @TheChampion,Just a reminder, the Brookses have nothing to do with hockey decisions. Even Denis Hamel was a Flyers signing. There are very few owners in the league with say in personnel decisions and the Brookses aren't one of them. Hockey operations is all Flyers. -- Tim McManus

  8. TheChampion
    Report Abuse
    TheChampion - March 23, 2012 10:35 am
    it really does make you wonder if the Brooks' are purposely trying to sabotage hockey in Glens Falls. I understand the Flyers have a majority stake in who plays here, but the best investment the Brooks' have made is a 40 year old who goes on hot streaks every few months. No offense to Denis, he's definitely been a great role model and a producer for the Phantoms, but consistancy isn't exactly something he seems familiar with.

    Makes me and many others who watch these games very nervous for next year. A lame duck year with ownership that has shown 0 interest. There really might be 1000 fans at every game next year. It's almost like Major League.

    We need to find ourselves a Jake Taylor.
  9. AHLTraveler
    Report Abuse
    AHLTraveler - March 23, 2012 9:44 am
    Interesting perspective here, Tim. Interesting primarily in the fact that you summarize what I have been posting here for the past three years. The Phantoms shortcomings are a direct result of two factors; poor drafting and poor scouting. It could be argued that it is difficult to draft stud players when so many high draft picks are traded for the likes of: Patrick Hersley, Jaroslav Modry, Marty Biron, Dan Carcillo and the infamous Steve Eminger. Conversely, trading picks for Prnger and Timonen can't really be questioned.

    Looking at the recent past history of the Flyers scouting raises many logical questions. Who really thought Kris Versteeg and Steve Eminger were worth 1st rounders? Why are so many top-end draft picks used to select players who never play any significant time in North America (Bertilsson, Bodrov, Kempe, Kovar)? There has also been a disturbing number of "AHL vets" who were signed that were either bad fits or past their prime. Greg Moore? Jason Ward?
  10. lifelong
    Report Abuse
    lifelong - March 23, 2012 7:06 am
    As a 2 seat season ticket holder since the Phantoms came to GF, I couldn't agree more with your excellent assessment of the current situation. I think the local fans should be applauded for continuing to spend their hard earned dollars on a team that the "powers to be" obviously care little about.


1) Comments must be contained to the topic of the articles only. Comments that stray from the direct subject of the article will be deleted.

2) Readers are free to comment on and debate other readers' comments, but comments must specifically address the issue(s) raised. Comments containing personal insults directed toward another reader in any form will be deleted.

3) Comments must be civil in tone, and there will be no name calling of any kind. Uncivil or inappropriate comments will be deleted, as will any comment containing profanities.

4) Comments critical of crime or accident victims will be deleted.

5) Comments that are potentially libelous, including those that contain accusations not supported by facts, will be deleted.

Commenters who abuse these policies will have their e-mail registrations revoked.


View the full commenting policy.

Thank you, and we hope you enjoy interacting with us and the community.

Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

Sports videos

Jeremy Johnson's walkoff homer wins it for Fort Ann

Fort Ann catcher Jeremy Johnson hit a walkoff three-run homer to lift Fort Ann to a 8-5 win over Whitehall.…

Tour of the Battenkill

Tour of the Battenkill

The 11th annual Tour of the Battenkill bicycle race around WashingtonCounty, starting at the…

Flames last game

Flames last game

The Adirondack Flames played their last ever game -- a 5-3 loss to Rochester -- and reflecte…

Greg Johnson nearly pitches perfect game, Lake George wins

Greg Johnson nearly pitches perfect game, Lake George wins

Greg Johnson's six innings of perfect baseball turned into a complete game one-hit shutout t…

Report results

Search Homes for Sale

Search Classifieds