Real Estate Upickem Golf

Who should pay what for services not cut, dry

2012-10-03T22:39:00Z Who should pay what for services not cut, dry Glens Falls Post-Star
October 03, 2012 10:39 pm

The suggestion from Jackson Supervisor Alan Brown that Washington County put a local income tax in place to relieve pressure on property owners is not as red a herring as it seems.

Counties in New York cannot impose income taxes, so Brown’s suggestion, interpreted narrowly, has no practical value. But when he said income taxes are more equitable than property taxes, he’s right, and it’s an inequity that could and should be addressed in a statewide reform of the tax code.

Numerous public programs — such as schools, public defender services, food stamps, heating assistance and Medicaid — are funded jointly by the counties with the state and federal governments.

The state’s money comes from income taxes paid by New York residents, the counties’ from property taxes.

Counties complain, with justification, the state requires them to offer certain services without providing enough funding. These unfunded mandates burden local governments, which are forced to raise more money in property taxes to cover the extra cost.

Many state-mandated programs, such as educational services for children with disabilities, are worthwhile. The problem is with the unfair distribution of property taxes.

Property taxes are borne disproportionately by the elderly, who in many instances own their own homes but are living on low, fixed incomes. High tax bills can threaten them with the loss of longtime family homes. People with middle-class incomes may inherit family camps that, because of the inflation in lakeside property values, carry property taxes that make the camps too expensive to maintain.

Farmers also can have modest incomes but own lots of land on which they must pay taxes.

State and local governments have addressed these inequities with partial and insufficient measures, such as the awarding of STAR tax breaks and designation of agricultural districts. Reform that is more comprehensive is needed.

The value of an individual’s house and land is an inaccurate measure of personal wealth. Some people with high incomes choose to live in modest homes, and because of that, pay less than their fair share of the cost of local services.

If local services were funded through income taxes, however, low-income taxpayers who own their own homes would have to pay less while high-income taxpayers would pay more.

Mr. Brown is not breaking new ground in identifying a problem with the way public services are funded in New York. The New York State Property Tax Reform Coalition has been advocating for years for a circuit-breaker bill to bring tax relief to property owners.

One of the coalition’s founders and its current legislative affairs officer is John Whiteley, who lives in Ticonderoga and is a thoughtful, articulate advocate. The state’s tax cap was a positive step, Mr. Whiteley said, but also a less substantive reform than a circuit breaker.

A circuit breaker limits the percentage of household income one taxpayer will have to pay in property taxes. Mr. Whiteley’s coalition presents an elegant explanation of the proposal on its website,

Shifting the local tax burden from property to income taxes would require an enormous political effort and reorganization of the tax collection and distribution system. But putting a circuit breaker in place is a much smaller and more doable undertaking.

Mr. Brown’s frustration with the welfare system, because people not paying property taxes receive services including food stamps and free legal representation, led to his suggestion the county should institute an income tax.

If you qualify for free legal representation or food stamps, however, you would likely not be subject to an income tax.

Nonetheless, Mr. Brown’s comments point to a longstanding inequity in our system. The tax cap was a good start, but Governor Andrew Cuomo and the Legislature should not stop there. We need broader tax reform.

Local editorials represent the opinion of The Post-Star editorial board, which consists of Publisher Rick Emanuel, Editor Ken Tingley, Projects Editor Will Doolittle and citizen representative Mark Bergman.

Copyright 2015 Glens Falls Post-Star. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(1) Comments

  1. DanaHaff
    Report Abuse
    DanaHaff - October 04, 2012 7:49 pm
    So if 47% of the National population pays no Federal Income Tax, do you think New York State or any NY County would be much different regarding collection of income tax? If this idea does away with Property Tax then I am all for it because with a Property Tax you never ever own your home no matter how many generations have lived there with a paid off mortgage. Stop paying your property taxes and see how long it takes before you are foreclosed upon by the County. But don't be fooled that a County income tax is a fairer way to collect funds because those that "do" will still pay for those that "don't". Consumption tax is the better way to go.


1) Comments must be contained to the topic of the articles only. Comments that stray from the direct subject of the article will be deleted.

2) Readers are free to comment on and debate other readers' comments, but comments must specifically address the issue(s) raised. Comments containing personal insults directed toward another reader in any form will be deleted.

3) Comments must be civil in tone, and there will be no name calling of any kind. Uncivil or inappropriate comments will be deleted, as will any comment containing profanities.

4) Comments critical of crime or accident victims will be deleted.

5) Comments that are potentially libelous, including those that contain accusations not supported by facts, will be deleted.

Commenters who abuse these policies will have their e-mail registrations revoked.


View the full commenting policy.

Thank you, and we hope you enjoy interacting with us and the community.

Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick


Search Homes for Sale

Search Classifieds