A local Republican Party official called on state Sen. Roy McDonald to end his re-election bid Wednesday as the GOP rallies around Saratoga County Clerk Kathy Marchione.

Marchione officially claimed victory over McDonald, R-Saratoga, Tuesday in the Republican primary, following days of absentee ballot counts in which she maintained a lead of more than 100 votes.

Now GOP officials, looking to maintain a tenuous majority in the state Senate, are hoping to unify the party leading up to the general election.

“I hope he will consider holding the Republican line strong,” said outgoing Saratoga County GOP Chairman Jasper Nolan, repeating concerns of some in the GOP that McDonald could fracture the party if he mounts a third-party bid.

Claverack Supervisor Robin Andrews is the Democratic candidate in the race for New York’s 43rd Senate District.

McDonald could run a third-party bid on the Independence Party line. His campaign has gone silent since Tuesday and is expected to make an announcement about the two-term senator’s future by early next week.

“I hope Roy will think of his background and success as a Republican through the years,” Nolan said.

McDonald’s once quarter-million-dollar war chest had dwindled to just $25,000 as of Sept. 20, according to campaign finance filings.

McDonald is one of three state Senate Republicans who met stiff primary challenges from the party’s conservative wing because they sided with Senate Democrats in support of gay marriage last year.

Senators Stephen Saland, R-Poughkeepsie, and Mark Grisante, R-Buffalo, narrowly survived primary challenges.

State Senate Republicans are expected to back Marchione officially as soon as the courts certify her victory, according to party officials.

The Senate GOP is fighting to retain a slim 33-29 majority. It’s the only wing of state government controlled by Republicans.

Former Sen. James Alesi, R-Rochester, the fourth Republican to support gay marriage, retired earlier this year amid criticism of his vote. He contributed $16,800 to McDonald’s campaign a week before the primary, according to campaign finance reports.

Marchione will also appear on the Conservative Party line in November.

(6) comments

the drifter


something is wrong

I feel the same way, couldn't of said it any better.


It's probably appropriate that Ms. Marchione is the GOP nominee, since opposition to civil rights, the only major difference (along w/abortion) between her and McDonald, is probably the majority opinion in that party.

Still, I hope Sen. McDonald runs in the general election. His job as senator was to represent ALL of the voters, not just the Tea Party Republicans. Therefore, ALL citizens should get to decide his fate. He shouldn't be thrown out just because a loud-mouthed fringe of the GOP hates him for upholding the constitution and his oath of office.


Very wisely said. He should take his orders from ALL the voters, not just from the party leaders.


He is not a Republican, hopefully he will just leave and do the right thing, but don't count on it.


This is a narrow minded one issue party. Congrats!!! This rat is leaving the ship.

Welcome to the discussion.

Comments will not be posted if any of the following rules are violated:
- Comments must be contained to the topic of the articles only.
- Comments must be civil in tone and cannot contain personal insults directed toward another reader.
- Profanities cannot be used, including abbreviations or acronyms.
- Comments critical of crime or accident victims are not allowed.
- Comments that imply guilt for those arrested are not allowed.
- Comments that are potentially libelous, including those that contain accusations not supported by facts are not allowed.
- Comments that appear to be taunting others who comment are not allowed.